Breaking Dawn Theories #4

[bronzehairedgirl]

Alright, time for thread number four. A few points to remember...

Watch the quoting. Quote small portions of the post you need to quote, or just reference the author of the post you are talking about. We should never see huge posts quoted.

And as always, be nice. There are lots of different theories out there as to what will happen in book 4. The only person who knows the real deal is Stephenie, and she's not telling.

And absolutely no more of this "I'll burn it if this happens" CRAP. You won't burn it, you're being overly dramatic.

Post your theories about what you think might happen in book 4.

Explore all characters, what will happen to the Pack, the Cullens, the regular humans...

For reference

Breaking Dawn Theories thread.
Breaking Dawn Theories #2
Breaking Dawn Theories #3

[Una]

I agree, the personality of Angela and her behavior leads me to believe that she is not a witch. I think that is just a red herring in the story. Gives us all something to ponder and write fan fiction about.

I can't see the Denali clan "helping" with Bella's transformation. Tanya (as it is implied) is quite fond of Edward. We do not know if she sees him as a soul-mate but depending on her desire for him, Irina would not upset her by changing Bella. Plus, Bella's transformation wouldn't really hurt the pack, they already know she wants this. It is only a question of time, something that Bella made fairly clear to Jacob.

[Conzoni al Vento]

Alright. I see your point. I also think that the Cullens wouldn't leave that big of a responsibility in their hands, now that I think about it .So now, the treay has to be broken.
People are saying that the treay doesn't even still count because they have all broken it, sort of. But it does exist still and the wolves will start a war if the Cullens screw up. They are spontaneous and needless to say- a little greedy and feel superior. so they can break their own rules, but the Cullens cannot. Jacob said it will be war,even.

[CamberXite]

Yeah I agree with Conzoni al Vento . I Personally think the treaty is just stupid!! But anyways , When/If Bella is turned , I don't think there will be a war , both parties have broken the treaty on numerous occasions , breaking it once more wouldn't do any harm , and I don't think Jake would let anything like that happen , I'm sure he wants Bella to be happy!

[Conzoni al Vento]

Jacob doesn't want Bella to be happy as much as he wants to save her from "dooming" herself and becoming a vampire and staying with him.

For a tiny little breakng of the treaty- im sure they won't say anything. But, if they bite her.. that's HUGE. They will totally only take that one bite into account and forget everything else.

[CamberXite]

Keep in mind that the Volturi will be up the Cullens butts about Bella changing.. That was their agreement , Im sure Jake wouldn't want Bella's life to be threatened by Jane? Or anyone of the Volturi for that matter ..

[FieryxLove]

I think Jacob will try to stop her transformation, even if it means sacrificing himself, which is very sad But I don't know. JAcob really loves her, and he knows that if she is changed, he has absolutly no chance with her and thats why he'll stop at nothing to stop it. Also, I think if she is bitten, Jacob will make sure there is a war. It just seems like something he'd do. *shrugs*

[malaz]

If there is a way - the cullens would win. back up a sec. They will have the denali clan, and voltri if they want. hey.

cullens + denali clan = 14 strong vampires against 10 werewolves, and half of them are new.

I am not saying there is a war. But at first jake said, if she was changed there will be a war, at the end of the book he's saying no!!

Biting Bella IS HUUUUGE, biggest part of the treaty. forget stepping on their land, they'll forget everything and focus on that. But don't you think, if Bella and Edward left. he changed her. How would the wolves know. for sure, Bella would never be able to come back. unless, jake invited her. ahaha, but still.

Bella could still be bit, and go to antartica -- how are the wolves going to get her there. the treaty will will officially be broken. but if they could get her, come and start it.

[Bella_Cullen_13]

I agree that Jacob really doesnt care as much for Bella's happiness as he does that she's becoming a vampire. I think he will probably try to stop her transformation, not so much the wedding. He accepts that she needs Edward to live, even if he doesnt like it, but he doesnt understand why she wants to 'kill' herself. He will think he's saving her.

[Una]

Remember the pack is more than just Jacob, he is not the Alpha, it wouldn't be his decision, it's Sam's. I'm not sure that Jacob would sacrifice himself to save Bella from being a vampire and/or marrying Edward. Jacob loves Bella and only wishes that she chose him. But he wants to see her happy, I don't think he would do something that drastic in order to keep her from her happiness. I think that is the main reason Jacob leaves at the end of Eclipse. To escape not only the pain of the rejection, but the bittersweetness that in Bella's choice to marry Edward means her transformation is to follow.

This is why I keep wondering why those highly intelligent people (Carlisle, Edward, Bella, etc) haven't figured out about injecting her with venom. If they can inject her with morphine to dull the transformation, why haven't they thought about how to turn a human into a vampire without biting.

I agree, Conzoni that Jacob would rather see her alive than hating him than happy as a vampire. However, that inner turmoil of right and wrong, protecting her and making her happy, is overwhelming him, Jacob's young and inexperienced. His is torn on the right course of action so he does what any young person would do, he runs away. Hopefully while he is away he will be able to figure it out.