Chapter Ten: The Meadow

Our chapter by chapter discussion of New Moon.
Nessie
Settled in Forks
Posts: 5
Joined: Fri Jun 08, 2007 8:33 am

Post by Nessie »

1. What did you think was wrong with Jacob? Were you as suspicious as Bella about his illness? I was suspicious, and was wondering about him being a werewolf.

2. When Laurent appeared out of the trees did you also think like Bella, that it was Edward? I did think it was Edward. I wanted him to come back!

3. When the wolves came out of the forest what were your thoughts? When one of them looked at Bella, did you suspect it was Jacob or that Edward was involved somehow? I wasn't scared of the (were)wolves because Laurent was scared of them. That was what further convinced me about Jacob.

4. At this point in the story did you already suspect that Jacob was a werewolf? Yup.

5. Did you think that now that Victoria was hunting Bella that Edward and the Cullen's would come back?
Yes.

Forevertopaz17
Hiding Lauren's Hair Dye
Posts: 470
Joined: Tue Apr 17, 2007 4:09 pm
Location: Defending Jacob Black

Re: Chapter Ten: The Meadow

Post by Forevertopaz17 »

Alphie wrote:These questions were prepared by ECABS.

1. What did you think was wrong with Jacob? Were you as suspicious as Bella about his illness?

2. When Laurent appeared out of the trees did you also think like Bella, that it was Edward?

3. When the wolves came out of the forest what were your thoughts? When one of them looked at Bella, did you suspect it was Jacob or that Edward was involved somehow?

4. At this point in the story did you already suspect that Jacob was a werewolf?

5. Did you think that now that Victoria was hunting Bella that Edward and the Cullen's would come back?
1. I wasn't completely sure. I really did think he was sick, because of that phone call at the end of chapter 9, but I wa a little suspicious, cause Jake would deffinately have called.

2. Well, I'm pretty sure I started breathing really fast and was screaming YES! in my head (I did think it was Edward) however, Laurent was ok. That meant there was at least a possibility of Edward coming back.

3. I just thought they were wolves. And when the big brown one looked at Bella, I just thought they were going to chase her or something.

4. I had no clue.

5. Totally, cause at that point I was still believing that that was really Edward talking to her, through some type of connection between them.
<a href="http://s246.photobucket.com/albums/gg96/forevertopaz17/?action=view&current=eclipse-1-1.jpg" target="_blank"><img src="http://i246.photobucket.com/albums/gg96/forevertopaz17/eclipse-1-1.jpg" border="0" alt="Photobucket"></a>
'I held you in my hand, Wanderer. And you were so beautiful.'
-Ian, The Host

johanna_cullen
Settled in Forks
Posts: 15
Joined: Sat Mar 10, 2007 2:15 am
Location: Forks's police station, arrested because I was stalking Edward Cullen

Post by johanna_cullen »

1. What did you think was wrong with Jacob? Were you as suspicious as Bella about his illness?
Yes ! I was ! There was something weird with it. I was also almost sure that there would be werewolves coming later in the story...


2. When Laurent appeared out of the trees did you also think like Bella, that it was Edward?

No ! I thought it was Victoria !

3. When the wolves came out of the forest what were your thoughts? When one of them looked at Bella, did you suspect it was Jacob or that Edward was involved somehow?
Obviously ! honestly, it was a little cliché ...

4. At this point in the story did you already suspect that Jacob was a werewolf?
Yup ! I did since Bella's dream ...

5. Did you think that now that Victoria was hunting Bella that Edward and the Cullen's would come back?
No, because at that point in the book I REALLY hate them for what they did to her... But I really can't remember what I thought at that time !
[img]http://i178.photobucket.com/albums/w248/incredible_johanna/signature_13.gif[/img]

"Am I tough ? Am I strong ? Am I hardcore ? Absolutely.Did I whimper with pathetic delight when I sank my teeth into my hot fried-chicken sandwich ? You betcha." -Maximum Ride-

Betting On Alice
Hiding Lauren's Hair Dye
Posts: 427
Joined: Sun Apr 01, 2007 2:15 pm
Location: In the Rain

Post by Betting On Alice »

1. What did you think was wrong with Jacob? Were you as suspicious as Bella about his illness?

I think I was. It seemed like a natural conclusion after all of the hints we get through out the book. It may have shocked me a little, but i honestly can't remember now.

2. When Laurent appeared out of the trees did you also think like Bella, that it was Edward?

I hoped it was Edward, and thought it was him for about the same amount of time Bella did. I realized it was Laurent a tad before she did, but not much.

3. When the wolves came out of the forest what were your thoughts? When one of them looked at Bella, did you suspect it was Jacob or that Edward was involved somehow?

I suspected it was Jacob, and that was where it hit me that Jake was a werewolf. When it talked about the intelligent brown eyes, it was a dead give away.

4. At this point in the story did you already suspect that Jacob was a werewolf?

Maybe suspect, but I didn't actually know until he looked at Bella.

5. Did you think that now that Victoria was hunting Bella that Edward and the Cullen's would come back?

Yes I did. I guess Edward thought he had it under control. :wink:
[img]http://i164.photobucket.com/albums/u33/trulyido/judgesbanner.gif[/img]
---Member of---
The RDP, COCL, Twilight Mafia, Team Edward, Team Bella, Quileutist

welshchick09
Jump Starting Bella's Truck
Posts: 166
Joined: Sun Jul 01, 2007 10:39 am
Location: Indiana

Post by welshchick09 »

[size=18]1. What did you think was wrong with Jacob? Were you as suspicious as Bella about his illness?

- Eh not really as soon as he began acting weird and feeling sick i just was like ah HA knew it. But somehow i always knew it was coming NETSPEAK IS SO UNATTRACTIVE PLEASE FIX ME! why probably because i've read Twilight and New Moon atleast 3 times each now.[/color]

2. When Laurent appeared out of the trees did you also think like Bella, that it was Edward?

-No, when edward left i knew he wouldnt stick around i thought maybe he's watching her but no i had a feeling it wasn't him.

3. When the wolves came out of the forest what were your thoughts? When one of them looked at Bella, did you suspect it was Jacob or that Edward was involved somehow?

-My first thought was OMG THIS IS AWESOME lol when jacob looked at Bella i really thought he would turn on her alittle. Yea i knew it was jacob just from how she desribed it.

4. At this point in the story did you already suspect that Jacob was a werewolf

-Yes i think everyone did kind of a dead give away.

5. Did you think that now that Victoria was hunting Bella that Edward and the Cullen's would come back?

-You know i didn't really expect Victoria too be that much of a problem so i'll admit i'm surprised that she;s turned into such a threat. But i knew that the Cullens would come back. i mean THEY HAD TOO

welshchick09
Jump Starting Bella's Truck
Posts: 166
Joined: Sun Jul 01, 2007 10:39 am
Location: Indiana

Post by welshchick09 »

[size=18]1. What did you think was wrong with Jacob? Were you as suspicious as Bella about his illness?

- Eh not really as soon as he began acting weird and feeling sick i just was like ah HA knew it. But somehow i always knew it was coming NETSPEAK IS SO UNATTRACTIVE PLEASE FIX ME! why probably because i've read Twilight and New Moon atleast 3 times each now.[/color]

2. When Laurent appeared out of the trees did you also think like Bella, that it was Edward?

-No, when edward left i knew he wouldnt stick around i thought maybe he's watching her but no i had a feeling it wasn't him.

3. When the wolves came out of the forest what were your thoughts? When one of them looked at Bella, did you suspect it was Jacob or that Edward was involved somehow?

-My first thought was OMG THIS IS AWESOME lol when jacob looked at Bella i really thought he would turn on her alittle. Yea i knew it was jacob just from how she desribed it.

4. At this point in the story did you already suspect that Jacob was a werewolf

-Yes i think everyone did kind of a dead give away.

5. Did you think that now that Victoria was hunting Bella that Edward and the Cullen's would come back?

-You know i didn't really expect Victoria too be that much of a problem so i'll admit i'm surprised that she;s turned into such a threat. But i knew that the Cullens would come back. i mean THEY HAD TOO

*Solar Eclipse*
Wandering Through Town
Posts: 46
Joined: Fri Apr 13, 2007 3:12 pm
Location: watching the cullens play baseball

Post by *Solar Eclipse* »

1. i wasn't sure what was wrong with jake though i knew it wasn't mono. i was as suspicious as bella.

2. i didn't think it was edward just because he left her and that.

3. i thought that the werewolves were the cullens or at least some of them and some how they found a way to change into gigantic wolves so edward could keep an eye on bella cause he still loves her.

4.no i am very blind on some things...

5. i thought that since edward was one of the wolves that he would morph back into a vampire and then come back to bella and protect her.
Hmpt!

chima15
Learning to Love Green
Posts: 98
Joined: Fri Jun 29, 2007 12:23 am
Location: In the Lime Light

Post by chima15 »

1. What did you think was wrong with Jacob? Were you as suspicious as Bella about his illness?

I sort of already knew he was a werewolf because look at his size and stuff, an ordinary teenager wouldnt be so HUGE, and all of the other things that were wrong.

2. When Laurent appeared out of the trees did you also think like Bella, that it was Edward?


No, I thought it was Jacob, or maybe her father hunting the 'bears'

3. When the wolves came out of the forest what were your thoughts? When one of them looked at Bella, did you suspect it was Jacob or that Edward was involved somehow?

I thought that the wolves were going to attack her. Yes, I did suspect it was Jacob. I knew Edward was not involved.

4. At this point in the story did you already suspect that Jacob was a werewolf?

Yes

5. Did you think that now that Victoria was hunting Bella that Edward and the Cullen's would come back?

No, because Edward said he would leave her alone, and I honestly thought that Jacod and his 'brothers' would finish her off. :D
[url=http://www.mybannermaker.com/link.php?nurl=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.mybannermaker.com][img]http://img359.imageshack.us/img359/1073/mybanner47d615be8b1b6zn9.jpg[/img][/url]

VMT Queen of Truth or Dare

TheLamb
Settled in Forks
Posts: 9
Joined: Sun Jul 01, 2007 11:23 am
Location: In my own little world.

Re: Chapter Ten: The Meadow

Post by TheLamb »

Alphie wrote:These questions were prepared by ECABS.

1. What did you think was wrong with Jacob? Were you as suspicious as Bella about his illness?

2. When Laurent appeared out of the trees did you also think like Bella, that it was Edward?

3. When the wolves came out of the forest what were your thoughts? When one of them looked at Bella, did you suspect it was Jacob or that Edward was involved somehow?

4. At this point in the story did you already suspect that Jacob was a werewolf?

5. Did you think that now that Victoria was hunting Bella that Edward and the Cullen's would come back?
1. Up until when Bella was in the meadow, I thought Jake had something wierd, not the same thing as Mike. I only thought that because he seemed, for the most part, fine the night before. I am very proud, however, to state that by the time Bella saw the warewolves in the woods, I was positive Jake was one of them. Bella thinking of Jacob right when the wolf right when the wolf looked her in the eyes was a hint, as were Billy's strong beliefs and, essentially, Jacob in Twilight when he was saying that vampires had only one enemy.

2. No. I didn't know who to think it was. It was too fast-paced for me to think anything really.

3.Like I said, I knew it was Jake from the moment he looked at her.

4. I didn't before. I had my suspicions about Billy, but it wasn't until the wolves showed themselves that I realized what was going on.

5. I hadn't given much thought to Victorea before Laurent arrived. She was a minor. I knew Edward was coming back anyway, though, because otherwise the story wouldn't be told. It wouldn't have a happy ending. Even Romeo and Juliet died together - of course the made-for-each-other couple would (if they die at all, that is.)
<center><img src="http://img295.imageshack.us/img295/8017/bannerbx5.jpg">
[i]Amazing Grace, how sweet the sound,
That saved a wretch like me!
I once was lost, but now am found,
Was blind, but now I see.[/i]

Isabella Cullen

Post by Isabella Cullen »

1. What did you think was wrong with Jacob? Were you as suspicious as Bella about his illness?
I wasn't sure at first, but when Bella tried a few times to call him and didn't get a response, I started to suspect something was up. I didn't know what on earth could possibly be getting Jacob, but whatever it was, it was making him act...odd.

2. When Laurent appeared out of the trees did you also think like Bella, that it was Edward?
My heart skipped a beat, yes. But I had a sneaky suspicion that it wasn't Edward. It wouldn't seem right, for him to just appear like that, after all that time had passed. What would his reason be for just spontaneously returning? And in their meadow, of all places?

3. When the wolves came out of the forest what were your thoughts? When one of them looked at Bella, did you suspect it was Jacob or that Edward was involved somehow?
My eyes were wide just like Bella's. I was afraid too for her because I wasn't sure what was going to happen. When one of the wolves (Bella's description of him really sparked something in my memory) looked at her, I knew it was Jacob. I don't know how I knew, I just did. It was kind of creepy. ^_^;;
Goodness knows if Jacob all of a sudden is involved, where would Edward be? I had no answer, and about a million questions racing through my mind.


4. At this point in the story did you already suspect that Jacob was a werewolf?
I knew he had to be. It all started to make sense. When he came to Bella later on talking about how he was wanting to keep his promise and how he subtly reminded her of the day he told her the stories and old Quileute legends, I instantly remembered everything. Jacob Black was a werewolf.

5. Did you think that now that Victoria was hunting Bella that Edward and the Cullen's would come back?
I was hoping and praying with all my heart that they would. I knew that if somehow Alice were to find out that Victoria was still alive and kicking and all the while hunting Bella, the Cullens would without a second thought, return to Forks.

Post Reply

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 6 guests