Page 6 of 7

Posted: Fri Jun 15, 2007 1:27 am
by I*choose*both
ugh.....sorry.....Phil...Paul...and a 4 hour flight accompaniied with a 5 hour drive. I'm sort of loony. Thanks for tellin me though I would have probably just ontinued ramblig about Paul :roll:

Posted: Fri Jun 15, 2007 6:07 pm
by slimgoodi17
i never paid much attention and for some time i though he played minor league basketball. I guess it's because Bella said something like playing ball and my mind jumped to basketball.

Personally, I wish he played minor league basketball

Posted: Wed Jun 20, 2007 7:31 pm
by ~*~Kelsey~*~
Everytime I think of Phil, I think that maybe the reason that Bella finds him annoying is because he is just one of those people that end up getting on your nerves. I also think that maybe he is one of those poeple that push everyone out of the way of him want to fillful his childhood dream... with the whole baseball playing he does, because from what I have heard he isn't like in any major leauge or anything. But with the same breath I think that he would make the perfect husband for Renee because she seems like she would need someone to take care of. Her motherly side needs that, and I believe that Bella realizes that and decied to get them some space. Sorry if you guys don't understand my rabmling (sp?)

Posted: Wed Jun 20, 2007 9:49 pm
by ShadowAmicasta
I dunno. I always kind'a liked Phil. He was the more spontaneous young thing that Renee needed and couldn't get from "middle-aged" Bella.

I got the impression that Bella and Phil got along, but didn't particularly understand each other more than it being a case of not liking each other.

I think it would be both interesting and painful if Phil and Charlie ever met. I think they would both be kind'a awkward around each other. And maybe Phil would make some corney jokes to try and lighten the mood, and maybe Charlie would make some cryptic remarks that could be interperted as jealous bitterness. And then maybe they'd accidentally start bonding over a sports game on TV. It could be cute, and Renee would just roll her eyes and start interogating Bella about her super hott boyfriend. :D

Posted: Tue Jul 03, 2007 12:48 pm
by vampire doll
is phil younger then renee? not that age matters ,but for some reason i keep thinknig hes younger?

Posted: Wed Jul 11, 2007 5:24 pm
by irunwithvampires
Now that I think about it more, I really want to see more of Phil. Actually, in general, I want to see more about Bella's old life in Pheonix and everything. It's not shown much at all...and I know Bella didn't have very many friends back home, but she must've had some. I think it'd be cool if she got to meet up with them again, and we got to see what her old life was like a little bit. Imagine Edward meeting her old friends. That'd be cool.

Posted: Thu Aug 09, 2007 11:45 pm
by Neave
Sorry if this has already been posted, but did anyone notice how when Bella and Edward visit Renee, he was gone alot because he "coaches high school baseball" and they were in the championships??? That is pretty funny. At least moderately funny. He must have never gotten signed, and now is just a high school coach... Too ad. So sad...

I have not been impressed with him. Seems perfect for Renee though...

Posted: Wed Aug 15, 2007 1:52 pm
by Sansa
I would love to know more about Phil. In the books, we only know him because of Renee is there, explaining things to Bella. Anyway, he seems a good guy, a little young for Renee, but it doesn't matter, they are happy together.

Posted: Sat Nov 03, 2007 12:26 pm
by evermoreimmortal
Phil is...meh. I don't really care about Phil. He kind of scares me, I don't know why...he's just not my favourite, or on my "Top 10 Twilight Characters That Matter To Me" List.

Posted: Sat Nov 03, 2007 3:13 pm
by TreeGoddess
I really do wish that we knew more about Phil other than the previously stated facts. It bothers me to not know anything about him other than he's Bella's step-father and the reason she moved to Forks. It kind of creeps me out to, not having the whole story.