Page 8 of 9

Posted: Thu Jul 10, 2008 9:35 pm
by Breathe Bella
Edl0ver wrote:WHAT IF...
Bella gets into trouble like in all the other books. then edward saves here from being killed completly but if he dosent turn her into a vampire right then she'll die just like with all the other cullens.
This is what I've been leaning towards lately... for several reasons.

1) In Eclipse doesn't Jacob say that the Treaty holds no boundaries for the biting clause. That if the Cullens bite, no matter where it is, it will mean war.

2) Even though Edward really would love Bella for all eternity it is clear that he holds the notion of Bella as human in the utmost regard and I would like to see him get his wish. For him to be witness to Bella finding her way in the human world and him living it through her vicariously

3) I would love to see Bella realise that she has some living to do before she commits to an existence with no alternatives. That she agrees to give Edward the time he's been begging her for and then finally ...

4) There kind of needs to be a danger for Bella in the finale. So given that she will no doubt be in peril at some stage wouldn't it be great if I get all the above wishes but sadly it will mean Bella's life/death if Edward doesn't change her and with this possibility Jacob is okay with her being changed and smooths things over with the pack.

Elaborate I know, but a girl can dream right?

Posted: Thu Jul 10, 2008 9:41 pm
by .dazzleme.
As much as i wish it would be in a meaningful place, like the meadow or something, i do have a feeling it wont be as easy like that. I'm thinking something will happen to bella, and edward is forced to change her in order to save her.

but yeah. i don't think it will be so easy. The book would be really short if it was just get married. get changed. I think there will be problems along the way.

Posted: Thu Jul 10, 2008 10:16 pm
by vampiregirlsince1918
It would be awesome if it all went smoothly, but if it did it would have to be away from people. So it happening in Chicago or in Forks wont really be possible I dont think. But most likely it will be something like alot have been saying were it'll be life or death for Bella so Edward will have to change, plus the pack would probley approve of that so she didnt die. But the main reason I'd rather it go more smoothly is just so she can have the morphine, I want her to be in as little pain as possible. I really really cant wait for Breaking Dawn comes out! I know after the party I'll be up reading all night. lol.

Re: Where would Edward change Bella?

Posted: Thu Jul 10, 2008 10:44 pm
by sarahbells
Bella_lookalike wrote: At first i said the Meadow but, then i remebered the treaty and he can't change her there. So i thought that they would have to move to another place before he changes her. But then again what about Charlie, Renne and Jacob? They wouldn't allow for her to move. This are the questions that haunt me. :D


I think he will pick a really romantic place because that is just the kind of guy he is but I also think it will be a obsure place. so no one can find them and stop it from happening just for bellas safety. I have no idea or i so not even have a speculation but I think these will be the qulafations of the place he chooses.

Posted: Fri Jul 11, 2008 2:58 pm
by Marissa06
I think Edward would obviously take Bella someplace where they were secluded and could be alone. Since the transformation would take a few days they would definitely need their privacy. Yet I wonder if Edward would want his family around just in case. At the end of Eclipse he mentions that maybe Carlisle could give Bella morphine to help with the pain. I think it would be easier on Edward if at least Carlisle were there so he could help if needed. But no matter what I think it will be far away from Forks and anyone else Bella knows, she wouldn't want to endanger anyone.

Posted: Fri Jul 11, 2008 5:06 pm
by Kelly in SD
I'm surprised so many think of Denali as a place of refuge when the Denali coven weren't there for the Cullens in their time of need.

Also, maybe it's just me but, knowing that Tanya wanted Edward herself, do you you really think that she would be at all helpful to Bella?

Posted: Fri Jul 11, 2008 5:20 pm
by BroadwayAmanda93
Kelly in SD wrote:I'm surprised so many think of Denali as a place of refuge when the Denali coven weren't there for the Cullens in their time of need.

Also, maybe it's just me but, knowing that Tanya wanted Edward herself, do you you really think that she would be at all helpful to Bella?
Wow. I never thought of it that way! Kudos! Especially about Tanya and Edward...I wonder if that'll be important to the story. Great, now I have another thing to worry about! :)

Posted: Fri Jul 11, 2008 6:33 pm
by mlola619
BroadwayAmanda93 wrote:
Kelly in SD wrote:I'm surprised so many think of Denali as a place of refuge when the Denali coven weren't there for the Cullens in their time of need.

Also, maybe it's just me but, knowing that Tanya wanted Edward herself, do you you really think that she would be at all helpful to Bella?
Wow. I never thought of it that way! Kudos! Especially about Tanya and Edward...I wonder if that'll be important to the story. Great, now I have another thing to worry about! :)
very true, i think Edward will want to make Bella's change in a place that has some sort of sentimental meaning to the both of them; granted the change isn't supposed to be romatic and lovely in any way since it is possibly one of the most painful things any of the Cullens have experienced- but i think SM is planning on having it done somewhere where no one would think of yet still would be like *crap! why didn't i think of that!?*

change

Posted: Fri Jul 11, 2008 6:42 pm
by katlovejay
Hey, where on Bella's body do you think Edward will bite her? I was thinking on her neck but then I thought everyone will be able to see it so that would not be a good idea. And, will they discuss it too?

Re: change

Posted: Fri Jul 11, 2008 6:46 pm
by mlola619
katlovejay wrote:Hey, where on Bella's body do you think Edward will bite her? I was thinking on her neck but then I thought everyone will be able to see it so that would not be a good idea. And, will they discuss it too?

o0o0o i never actually thought of that! hmm...i know it sounds cheezy but i think it would be somewhere significant for both of them...hmm....great, another BD question that will haunt me 'til August 2nd! haha