Page 1 of 11

Should Bella be a Vampire?

Posted: Thu Mar 30, 2006 1:17 am
by cheeto
Do you think Bella should become a vampire? I personally think in the next books she shouldn't. But maybe she should at the end of the very last book.

I like reading about Bella as a human because I can connect with her more. But then she should be with Edward forever. So what are your thoughts?

Posted: Thu Mar 30, 2006 1:31 am
by paledawn
I think she should be turned into a vampire, it would pain both of them too much for her to grow older and eventually die and him to exist forever. But I think she should wait until she is out of high school. I also love her as a human though, she reminds me of me!

Posted: Thu Mar 30, 2006 7:01 am
by Diana
I was wondering, in Twilight something was said about when you turn into a vampire your human memories fade (my friend has my book so I cant find the line), if Bella becomes a vampire, will she lose her memories with Edward? And if so, how long would they linger after the transformation?

Posted: Thu Mar 30, 2006 7:32 am
by Lomesir22
I don't think Bella would ever fully forget Edward. As for Edward turning her... only if she was truly dying. Honestly, I hope he (or someone else) does turn her, as I choke up whenever I remember this fanfiction that someone wrote where Edward didn't turn her and she grew old and died.

Posted: Thu Mar 30, 2006 8:51 am
by Bloodrose
I would love to see bella as a vampire ,to see how it feels for her to turn and if she thinks it has been complete worth it (which i think it would be ) but also because then we would get to see the world of forks threw the eyes of a vampire ,the new senses that would be final put to paper for us to read.

Posted: Thu Mar 30, 2006 9:41 am
by Alphie
Yes, human memories fade, but if Bella were a vampire, she would be with Edward forever, thus she wouldn't forget him because he would be with her. Does that make sense?

The main issue with Bella being a vampire for me is that the very thing that initially drew these two people together would be gone. Bella would lose her humanity and Edward would lose his mystery. I don't think it would end up ruining the relationship, but it is something to worry about. In the end though, I will cry if she doesn't make Bella a vampire. Honestly. Like Alice says - Edward has been alone for so long. What would it do to him to lose Bella now that he has found her? I think edward would be lost without her, and vise versa. So what I think will happen is that they will continue to fight about her mortality for New Moon and most of Eclipse, but then he will come to his senses - or be forced to change her.

Stephenie is probably reading this and LAUGHING at me. She does that, you know. And she gets a kick out it.

Posted: Thu Mar 30, 2006 9:56 am
by my_disadvantage
yesyesyes! i hope so! i love Bella anyway : >

Posted: Thu Mar 30, 2006 9:57 am
by my_disadvantage
oh, my message wasn't quite right so; i'd like to see Bella as vampire :>

Posted: Thu Mar 30, 2006 3:24 pm
by xBellax
Well its already hinted at that Alice did see Bella changed and thats why Edward is trying so stubbornly to keep her human. Silly boy trying to fight destiny.

I think Bella should be turned. I mean yes, she wouldnt be human anymore and the bit of "forbidden love" they had going on wouldnt be there anymore but the love itself would still be there. I think she'd like it too that perhaps Rosalie wouldnt treat her terribly anymore either. I think Bella just really wants Edwards family to accept her and all of them have but Rose.

I think she will too. I mean. "New Moon" implies a new beginning like how the new moon is the phase before the cycle starts again. Im thinking, and yea I know I have waaaay too much time on my hands, that she'll be turned by the end of the second book. Maybe the third. Im thinking Edward will be forced to turn her because of who knows what but Im pretty sure that Stephanie didnt post the cover for book three because it shows Bella as a vampire or something like that that shows shes been changed.

Yea Im crazy. I know. I enjoy it.

Posted: Thu Mar 30, 2006 4:55 pm
by EssenceofLife
Yes, I'd love to see Bella changed and (I'm already thinking ahead) I
always wondered what sort of super ability,i guess you could say, she'd have
like.. I know she picks up on things alot. she's pretty perceptive.