Should Bella be a Vampire?

General discussion about the Twilight Series Universe.
Post Reply
aKissAtTwilight
Settled in Forks
Posts: 12
Joined: Tue Mar 28, 2006 7:28 pm

Post by aKissAtTwilight »

i agree with that. i dont think, even though i would prefer, her turning into a vampire in the 2nd book. but i guess it does make more sense for her to turn in the thrid! hopefully she odes. and alos i think she would be more around the 18-19 yrs old. since on her site i think it said that there isnt that much time passing between the second and the third books?? but in the first and second it totally skips the summer break. i dont know but i think thats how it is.
Aranel
Settled in Forks
Posts: 6
Joined: Tue Mar 28, 2006 7:28 pm
Location: OR
Contact:

Post by Aranel »

I think it'd be cool if Bella was changed to a vampire in the second book, and then we could see what it was like for her through the 3rd book.
sadie_leona
Vampire Military Strategy Consultant
Posts: 93
Joined: Tue Mar 28, 2006 7:28 pm
Location: Camp Grayling, Michigan, blowing things up with the boys
Contact:

Post by sadie_leona »

I hope Bella gets changed before she reaches 19 or before she really changes much because it would be so depressing if Edward has to see her grow older than him (I mean in the body sense). I think she will eventually have to get changed by some vampire, because she has to meet some serious life threatening peril or injuries. She just has to.
<a href="http://www.TickerFactory.com/">
<img border="0" src="http://tickers.TickerFactory.com/ezt/d/4;0;2/st/20090901/e/West+Point+Military+Acad./dt/-1/k/318f/event.png"></a>
Jess
Settled in Forks
Posts: 17
Joined: Wed Mar 29, 2006 5:34 pm
Location: new jersey
Contact:

Post by Jess »

I agree with Alphie - the attraction would somewhat be lost like her warm skin and the smell of her blood but he has fallen in love with her personality too. Perhaps when (i'm hoping) Bella becomes a vampire her "smell" might be even more alluring to him though.
One thing about her becoming a vampire (as said in the end of Twilight) is that she would never be able to see Charlie or her mother again and i think that is simply something Edward would never be able to do to her meaning i think at some point Bella would have to be close to death for Edward to change her - maybe because of an accident or another vampire attack? Or she could be changed by another vampire.
aKissAtTwilight
Settled in Forks
Posts: 12
Joined: Tue Mar 28, 2006 7:28 pm

Post by aKissAtTwilight »

if it does happen it would probably be because she would die if he didnt do it or something.

also if they she just wanted him and thats it...then that would be to great. because in the book it talked about how james wanted alice but after she was changed he lost interest. was it just because she was a vampire now or was it because her sent changed along wiht it?!?! so if bella was changed do you think that he would want to be ith her as much as he does when she is human??
MarISsaBellA
Settled in Forks
Posts: 7
Joined: Fri Apr 07, 2006 9:14 am
Location: Memphis, Tennessee
Contact:

Post by MarISsaBellA »

Wow! I'm soo glad i finally have PEOPLE to talk about this amazing book with! (seeing as how my friends have differnt reading interests).

All of you guys make really great points and predicions! Geewillikers, i have so much to say and i ask i don't evern know where to start!

ok..i think in Twilight, i dont have the book with me now, but James said sometheing about how Alice DID smell good. as in she doesnt any more. And i think Stephenie said that after a yr of so vampires dont have any blood. so through logical reasoning im guessng if Bella is changed that she will lose her smell...? i really wish Ms. meyer would make an exception with Bella, and maybe changing her, beucase she is so human, would only add to her alluring smell, making Edward even more crazy about her...i can only dream.. :wink:

but as for Edward losing interest in her or whatever, Rosalie and Emmet still seem in love, as well as Carlisle and Esme. But i just feel that if Edward chagnes Bella the suspense and intrigue will die..i mean sure they will develop a strong love and friendship over the years for each othr..but after many years of being togher...i mean like for Rosalie and Emmett for example: im sure when Rosalie first changed Emmett they were new lovers and it was excting like Bella and Edward are now...but now there like jsut another part of the familly..does that make sense? Because now Bella and Edward are the Exciting new couple in the family untill he changes her and 10 years or so down the line there will be another new and exciting love addition to the Cullen family and it wnt be about Edward and Bella anymore...maybe thats just my crzy ranting and raving getting the better of me.

And when Bella loses her smell when she is changed, what if Edward comes across another human that smells outrageously good? after 100 yrs or so would he ever leave Bella for an excting love fling with the first human that smells good? i mean dont get me wrong, i HOPE not..but i just want to know what you guys think?

it does bother me though that Bella is going to be older than Edward.

** as for Edward changing into a human, it is possible if Stephenie would be willing to work a little withcraft into the play. I'm some spell could make the transformtion. It would probably be a very difficult-almost-impossible- spell though, that would add intirgue to a story tryng to accomplish it. or some other spell or other that wold allow bella to remain immortal at her age! again...wishful thinking here

i want bella and Edward to be madly in love forever but if she changes she won't be the special-human-girl-anymore. does anyone feel me?

I still have about a bajillion more things to say and ask about, but its lunch time.
Again, i'm sooooo0o0o glad to talk with yall! take care!
Adieu!

~MarissaBella


[/i]
aKissAtTwilight
Settled in Forks
Posts: 12
Joined: Tue Mar 28, 2006 7:28 pm

Post by aKissAtTwilight »

dang you have good points!!

haha. ok but yea. see thats what i thought. that she would loser her alluring smell that he initially feel for!! i dont think thta he woulod go after another human that had a good sent though. and if he EVER did i would EXTREMLY upset. :evil: haha...ok but yea. i dont htink that would ever happen cause its not only her smell that he is in love with. i mean the fact that her cant read her mind and he wants o know what she is thinking at like at all times?!?! does that make any sense?? ok well...and he thinks that hse is intesting and she "facinates" him. ahaha...i a little quote from the book.

you know if bella did turn into a vapire maybe she would keep her sent?? cause it says that sometimes whent hey turn into a vampire they bring special gifts!! and alot of people are kind of drawn to bella like mike, eric, and tyler. so maybe she would like draw people in?!?! i dont know if that makes any sense??? but yea...like she wuld draw edward in by her sent that she might keep!!!! i dont kow....

but as for edward into a human. how could that happen. i meanhe has been "dead" for like 100 yrs!!!!!. yea there could be some sort of spell...but do they even HAVE spells. OMG!! you know the book store in the chatpter "Port Angeles" maybe the lady in there has a part in the book!! and she is like some kind of witch?!?! cause ya know how it said that there were like dream catchers and all that mystical stuff?!?! YEA!!!
michL87
Officially Bitten Avatar Queen
Posts: 213
Joined: Wed Mar 29, 2006 7:02 pm
Location: Baltimore, MD

Edward as a human

Post by michL87 »

To the whole "Edward as a human theory":
Technically, Edward is around 100 years old (more or less.) Personally, I think a lot of his sexiness comes from being a vampire, and would rather see Bella changed into a vampire than Edward as a human.

But back to the theory. IF he were changed back into a human, would he look like a 100 year old man?

I just do not see how a "dead" body can turn alive again. It kind of reminds me of taking a piece of old meat out of a freezer and transforming it into an alive and mooing cow.
.... but then again, the vampire thing is all fantasy, so I suppose anything could happen :wink:
[img]http://www.stevensplanet.com/michl/myspace/leah/banner2.jpg[/img]


[url=http://www.myspace.com/michlayouts]MySpace Layouts[/url] - My MySpace Layouts. Some of them relate to Twilight.
aKissAtTwilight
Settled in Forks
Posts: 12
Joined: Tue Mar 28, 2006 7:28 pm

Post by aKissAtTwilight »

yea see i tought about that too....

i mean i think it would be more proabable if he were more recently turned into a vampre...but 100 yrs?? yea...that would bea little much
Artjerk528
Buying a Better Raincoat
Posts: 54
Joined: Sun Apr 09, 2006 9:03 pm
Location: Pennsylvania-Where I thrive

Changes in the life

Post by Artjerk528 »

Si, Si I think that anything is possible with these books. I mean Bella COULD become a vampire and keep her alluring gifts, and yet then again Edward could become human and not like update himself to the 100 year old man, but rather Starting where his life was cut short. Anyone seen Van Helsing here? That is what it reminds me of, bringing back the dead.
<a href="http://www.TickerFactory.com/">
<img border="0" src="http://tickers.TickerFactory.com/ezt/d/4;31;5/st/20060928/e/New+Moon+Signing/k/bf45/event.png"></a>

I love Oatmeal-its Delectable

and Arcade Fire, A7X, Coheed and Cambria, My Chemical Romance, Flyleaf, Armor for Sleep, Muse, Bloodhound Gang, and More!!!!
Post Reply

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 9 guests