Would you rather be on a island with Harry Potter or Edward

[Erendis]

I'd definitely want to be stranded with Edward. Also, I'm not a fan of HP and Edward is way smarter and more handsome.

[CamberXite]

I'd deffo be with Harry, then we can Accio Edward!

[Alice's Twin Sister]

Well My choice would be the suave, sexy, and romantic Edward Cullen of course! Harry isn't that romantic. Magic is overrated. Hmm and I loved Harry Potter books too!

[...Cristina...]

Edward...obviously...
I would rather stay on a desert island forever with him, than Harry...Edward is everything: beauty, intelligence, he's a vampire!!! Definitely Edward!!!

[dazzled-by-edward]

Edward Cullen, of course. why would anyone pick Harry when you could be alone with edward?

[Alice's Twin Sister]

Harry Potter may be able to cast some spell to get you off the island, and I know that I've had a big crush on Harry Potter for a long time. But come on. It's Edward Cullen. He could love you. And could keep you safe on the island and love you. And if not that then he could swim off the island to get someone to come save you. Or take you with him to safety. Think about it. Edward Cullen or Harry Potter? It's common sense.
Then again you could be stuck on the island with Harry Potter and have him cast a spell for Edward Cullen to be on the island too. :]
What a good idea. :]

Heck I wouldn't want to even leave the island if I had Edward Cullen with me! I could stay right there forever in blissful happiness.

[Devious Cullen]

On an island? What happens when all the animals have been used up as a food source. Eeep.

[vampires are life]

1st I must ask do you truley believe that edward has to eat so much that he would clear an entire island of food before any animals could reproduce? In the books he doesn't have to eat very often so I think that is unlikely.

2nd I would have to choose edward. Though I am a fan of Harry Potter he is not the same. What I mean is that edward is sweet and caring and Harry is just trying to save the world. So with that being said having edward with me would make being stranded much easier to handle while harry would let down the world cause he wouldnt be able to save it and voldemort would take over. so I vote for Edward.

[Devious Cullen]

It was a joke, lighten up.

[vampires are life]

I wasnt directing that at you. but now that I read it again I guess it looks like I was, sorry. I was just saying...