What if it all ends by Edward actually dieing?

General discussion about the Twilight Series Universe.
rapid_reader
Fishing with Charlie
Posts: 832
Joined: Sun Dec 30, 2007 4:52 pm
Location: 15 more days until Breaking Dawn comes out!

Post by rapid_reader »

I think she would fall apart (like I would!) and will be depressed maybe to the point of suicide. After all, it would be so much worse if edward died rather then left. Bella said in NM that she needed to know that he still existed out there somewhere for her to live. I think the thought of suicide would enter her mind many times, but I can only hope she sticks in there. I don't think Steph. would make Bella die though, this is a young adult novel and that would be way to...extreme for young adults.
[img]http://i246.photobucket.com/albums/gg112/Twilight001/Banners%20for%20TSBM/frenchproject12.jpg[/img]
Thank you to Twilight<3 for the awesome banner! =D
Click [url=http://www.twilightlexiconforum.com/viewtopic.php?t=18378&start=0]here[/url] to go to the SKITS thread!
Also, for the TSBM website, [url=http://twilightskitsbanners.aforumfree.com/index.htm]click here.[/url]
And check out Banana*Bear's amazing chat site [url=http://messing-with-life.forummotion.com/index.htm]here![/url]
ashleydash
Banging out dents with Tyler
Posts: 334
Joined: Sat Dec 29, 2007 8:38 pm
Location: New Zealand
Contact:

Post by ashleydash »

rapid_reader wrote:Has anyone listened to My Chemical Romance's song 'Leave Out All The Rest'? it's really sad, but I think it might be a good playlist song if Edward does die (shutter).
Isn't that a Linkin Park song? hahah
rapid_reader wrote:That would be HORRIBLE! :cry:

It would be like Harry Potter dieing in Deathly Hallows. It can't happen! For the sake of us and the sake of our hearts staying in one piece! If Edward died I think my and Bella's reaction would be somewhat similar.

But what would happen if he died? Would the Volutri change Bella into a vampire? Using her to work for them? Would Bella just be forgotten? With all the danger gone and Edward dead (shutter)? Would she run away and live with Renee? What would happen?
I agree! Especially with the Harry Potter part. The series would have no more meaning without Edward in my opinion.
Luminescence
Jump Starting Bella's Truck
Posts: 110
Joined: Fri Oct 19, 2007 6:21 pm
Location: Somewhere Over the Rainbow

Edward Dying

Post by Luminescence »

First of all, can we please spell dying correctly? (Note thread name) For the sake of my sanity? :(

Edward dying I think is pretty unrealistic. Let's examine the books. When Edward left Bella, we got the depressed Bella/heartbroken fans/New Moon generally being in spot #3 of favorite Twilight book (that's just what I've noticed, I'm not saying by any means that's true for all of us). We, as a fanbase, have already suffered big time with Bella. She was virtually dead when he LEFT her. And if he DIED... the entire book would be totally out of whack. I think Bella would die also, like the dogs at the end of Where The Red Ferns Grow.

It's just not logical. Edward was already close to death once, and I don't think that would happen again.
[img]http://i49.photobucket.com/albums/f292/outsider101/PANIC%20at%20the%20disco/spencer%20smith/spencer%20smith%20icons/omgitsspencer.png[/img][img]http://i212.photobucket.com/albums/cc28/sodesperatelyobvious/Panic%20Icons/326.jpg[/img][img]http://i212.photobucket.com/albums/cc28/sodesperatelyobvious/Panic%20Icons/285.jpg[/img][img]http://i22.photobucket.com/albums/b324/aquatic_fire_gem/Kaylens%20icons/AFI%20Icons/ICONATOR_065e2402f05ac6a2d55eb2150d.jpg[/img]
cullen4lyf
Buying a Better Raincoat
Posts: 64
Joined: Mon Aug 06, 2007 11:40 am
Location: somewhere trying to find the cullens and ask to be turned into a vampire.
Contact:

Post by cullen4lyf »

Ok this thread is giving me chills! ima die myself if Edward dies! i mean i seriously don't think that Stephenie would do that! i mean she would have to be...insane! or out of her mind of something! and that would just be like the end of the world to me.
*vampirez rule*
rapid_reader
Fishing with Charlie
Posts: 832
Joined: Sun Dec 30, 2007 4:52 pm
Location: 15 more days until Breaking Dawn comes out!

Re: Edward Dying

Post by rapid_reader »

Luminescence wrote:First of all, can we please spell dying correctly? (Note thread name) For the sake of my sanity? :(

Edward dying I think is pretty unrealistic. Let's examine the books. When Edward left Bella, we got the depressed Bella/heartbroken fans/New Moon generally being in spot #3 of favorite Twilight book (that's just what I've noticed, I'm not saying by any means that's true for all of us). We, as a fanbase, have already suffered big time with Bella. She was virtually dead when he LEFT her. And if he DIED... the entire book would be totally out of whack. I think Bella would die also, like the dogs at the end of Where The Red Ferns Grow.

It's just not logical. Edward was already close to death once, and I don't think that would happen again.
Exackly! Here Here! No one wants to go through the heartbreak of Edward dying. No one. Remember what Steph. said about NM, how she was often living Bella's pain through her own tears? I don't think she wants to go through that pain again.
Last edited by rapid_reader on Mon Dec 31, 2007 7:42 pm, edited 1 time in total.
[img]http://i246.photobucket.com/albums/gg112/Twilight001/Banners%20for%20TSBM/frenchproject12.jpg[/img]
Thank you to Twilight<3 for the awesome banner! =D
Click [url=http://www.twilightlexiconforum.com/viewtopic.php?t=18378&start=0]here[/url] to go to the SKITS thread!
Also, for the TSBM website, [url=http://twilightskitsbanners.aforumfree.com/index.htm]click here.[/url]
And check out Banana*Bear's amazing chat site [url=http://messing-with-life.forummotion.com/index.htm]here![/url]
cullen4lyf
Buying a Better Raincoat
Posts: 64
Joined: Mon Aug 06, 2007 11:40 am
Location: somewhere trying to find the cullens and ask to be turned into a vampire.
Contact:

Re: Edward Dying

Post by cullen4lyf »

Luminescence wrote: Edward dying I think is pretty unrealistic. Let's examine the books. When Edward left Bella, we got the depressed Bella/heartbroken fans/New Moon generally being in spot #3 of favorite Twilight book (that's just what I've noticed, I'm not saying by any means that's true for all of us). We, as a fanbase, have already suffered big time with Bella. She was virtually dead when he LEFT her. And if he DIED... the entire book would be totally out of whack. I think Bella would die also, like the dogs at the end of Where The Red Ferns Grow.

It's just not logical. Edward was already close to death once, and I don't think that would happen again.
Exactly! i mean New Moon is on the botom of my list! psh! i literaly threw the book acros my room when i read that Edward left! [well not realy because i would brake it but i felt like it!] but imagine if he dies! ha! that would be the end of me! it would be my worst nightmare! And mostlikely a bunch of other peoples! And i agree, IT IS JUST NOT LOGICAL!!!!!!
*vampirez rule*
ashleydash
Banging out dents with Tyler
Posts: 334
Joined: Sat Dec 29, 2007 8:38 pm
Location: New Zealand
Contact:

Post by ashleydash »

People keep comparing Edward and Bella to those two stories Romeo + Juliet and Pride and Prejudice.
I think that the Romeo and Juliet influence was in New Moon, and it's pretty much gone now.
I still think Edward won't die.
Because that leaves the story with no original meaning, and how many stories do you know have one main character dieing and the other commiting suicide (other than Romeo and Juliet influenced tales)
Not in teen fiction.
Bare in mind these are essentially younger people books.
The hero never dies ;) hahaha
...yes, I'm making excuses for him not to haha. I don't want him to =[
rapid_reader
Fishing with Charlie
Posts: 832
Joined: Sun Dec 30, 2007 4:52 pm
Location: 15 more days until Breaking Dawn comes out!

Post by rapid_reader »

ashleydash wrote:People keep comparing Edward and Bella to those two stories Romeo + Juliet and Pride and Prejudice.
I think that the Romeo and Juliet influence was in New Moon, and it's pretty much gone now.
I still think Edward won't die.
Because that leaves the story with no original meaning, and how many stories do you know have one main character dieing and the other commiting suicide (other than Romeo and Juliet influenced tales)
Not in teen fiction.
Bare in mind these are essentially younger people books.
The hero never dies ;) hahaha
...yes, I'm making excuses for him not to haha. I don't want him to =[
yes exackly! It's to extreme for a YA novel. I don't think it should or will happen. Edward is beloved by all and it would ruin the series.
[img]http://i246.photobucket.com/albums/gg112/Twilight001/Banners%20for%20TSBM/frenchproject12.jpg[/img]
Thank you to Twilight<3 for the awesome banner! =D
Click [url=http://www.twilightlexiconforum.com/viewtopic.php?t=18378&start=0]here[/url] to go to the SKITS thread!
Also, for the TSBM website, [url=http://twilightskitsbanners.aforumfree.com/index.htm]click here.[/url]
And check out Banana*Bear's amazing chat site [url=http://messing-with-life.forummotion.com/index.htm]here![/url]
cullen4lyf
Buying a Better Raincoat
Posts: 64
Joined: Mon Aug 06, 2007 11:40 am
Location: somewhere trying to find the cullens and ask to be turned into a vampire.
Contact:

Post by cullen4lyf »

rapid_reader wrote:
ashleydash wrote:People keep comparing Edward and Bella to those two stories Romeo + Juliet and Pride and Prejudice.
I think that the Romeo and Juliet influence was in New Moon, and it's pretty much gone now.
I still think Edward won't die.
Because that leaves the story with no original meaning, and how many stories do you know have one main character dieing and the other commiting suicide (other than Romeo and Juliet influenced tales)
Not in teen fiction.
[A SINGLE LETTER? WHY ON EARTH WOULD ANYONE USE A SINGLE LETTER TO REPLACE AN ENTIRE WORD?????????]Bare in mind these are essentially younger people books.[/A SINGLE LETTER? WHY ON EARTH WOULD ANYONE USE A SINGLE LETTER TO REPLACE AN ENTIRE WORD?????????]
The hero never dies ;) hahaha
...yes, I'm making excuses for him not to haha. I don't want him to =[
yes exackly! It's to extreme for a YA novel. I don't think it should or will happen. Edward is beloved by all and it would ruin the series.
Whatever you say why it wont happen ill take it. ha ha ha
the thing is for Edward to not die! Without a doubt the book would fall apart if that happens. It has to be imposible. atleast it is imposible in my world.
*vampirez rule*
Don'tBotherMeImReadingBD
Settled in Forks
Posts: 13
Joined: Mon Dec 31, 2007 1:08 pm

Post by Don'tBotherMeImReadingBD »

White Shadow wrote:Ok, everyone. Calm down and take some deep breaths.

Whenever something negative comes up I think it's always an excellent idea to turn to what I think has pretty much become the official lexicon mantra...

Stephenie likes happy endings, Stephenie likes happy endings, Stephenie likes happy endings...

Honestly, I don't think there's much chance at all of Stephenie killing off Edward. I really don't.
i cant talk it never crossed my mind until now! all i can say is NO NO NO NO NO NO NO we cant give in to the jacob lovers!never never never NEVER! i hear ya sista "knuckle touch!" hehe EDWARD WILL LIVE FOREVER it was meant to be. no i dont mean Bella and Edward thats the obvious reason yes them but I fell in love with edward, well i fall in love with a lot of fictional characters but HEY! its more true with edward! i pray to God for more Edwards in the world! when i see a hot guy i picture diamonds everywhere i show a little neck! come on people i will burn all the books... well no i wont just Breaking dawn...but i will! so NO NO NO NO! dont even think about it Stephenie if it happens i will hunt you down and bit-.... okay im going to sstop this now (keep telling yourself that Brooke) (dont give in to the evil monster!) okay keeping it pg-13 (NO dont bottle things up inside) i apologise my little shoulder pets they get a little testy when i get mad. but my last and final words to you about this is NO STEPHENIE NO!
"I never thought I'd see the day where I'd be willing to take a bet against you, Alice, but it has arrived. -Bella Swan

[url=http://www.mybannermaker.com/][img]http://img183.imageshack.us/img183/5336/mybanner477c0de840a3fxv9.jpg[/img][/url]
Post Reply

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 11 guests