If you were Bella...

[leahfellinlovwithtwilight]

if i was bella...................
well, i wouldnt have led jacob on knowing i was still in love with edward (dont deny it! she even said so herself!)
also, when he left, i would not have tried to follow him. i would have just lost myself in the woods going in no particular direction. i would have jumped off the cliff. for sure. i also would have gotten rid of the motorcycles so jake couldnt sell me out :]]

[sarahbells]

Would you have done anything differently than Bella? Would you have kissed Jacob? What would you have done when Edward left? Would you have jumped off the cliff?

This is the place to explain what you would have done differently than Bella and how it may have affected the events afterwards. You do not need to stick only to the questions I posed above. You can discuss any of Bella's actions you personally would do differently.

I think everthing in new moon that bella did was expected and I would of done the same. but I am not that sure about eclipse. Mabe I just dont like jake or I do not understand the emotions of their relationship but I would of not kisses him. I would love edward way to much to do that. but once again I am not sure I could say that with 100 percent suraty without being in that position.

[Raphael1989]

I would've chosen Jacob. Plain and simple.

And I don't think that I would have ever fallen in love with Edward. I would have chosen to stay away from him (I am placing my brain in Bella's body and going from there lol). Because Edward creeps. me. out.

[ViolettaCullen]

If I were Bella I wouldn't have jump off the cliff, because I would have die from a broken heart at the exact moment that Edward would have told me that he doesn't want me anymore
BUT if I had survived I would have kick myself for KISSING Jacob

[Marissa06]

If I were Bella then I would have never kissed Jacob. I wouldn't have led him on so that he thought there was a chance of being together. That is where most of the annoyances come from. I would have made it clear that I loved Edward and nothing could or would change that, even if we weren't together right then. I would have been grateful for Jacob's friendship, but the second I realized that he was feeling more for me than I him, I would have talked to him about it and stopped seeing him as much if necessary. I might have jumped off the cliff still though. I really relate to Bella, and if I were desperate enough to hear Edward's voice, why not? Of course I wouldn't jump if I thought I were going to get seriously hurt or something. I wouldn't want to hurt anybody else from my actions. Finally, when Edward came back I would have fully accepted that I shouldn't hang around Jacob. He is far more invested in the relationship and I would be fully committed to Edward, I realize Bella is, but I would easily be able to give up Jacob Black for him.

[ashley_nicole00]

I wouldnt have done much different if I were Bella. I think all things considered, she did pretty well to at least try to pretend that she was going to survive for Charlie. I probably would have curled up in a ball and not gotten up for like, forever...

I think that the people who are mocking her 'irrational' and 'risky' behaviors just to hear Edwards voice are kind of rude. She was trying to hold on to one part of him that she had found a way to remember perfectly. They were in love beyond the high school crush phase and he meant the world to her, and so it only right that her world went crashing after he abandoned her. (I totally understand and am okay with why Edward left though.) I totally would have jumped off the cliff too, but I doubt I would have quit fighting like she did. Its not like she was trying to commit suicide at first. She actually thought the reason she was so restless and edgy was that she hadn't heard Edwards voice for too long, and she was just trying to get it back.

[sunandair]

Would you have done anything differently than Bella? Would you have kissed Jacob? What would you have done when Edward left? Would you have jumped off the cliff?

This is the place to explain what you would have done differently than Bella and how it may have affected the events afterwards. You do not need to stick only to the questions I posed above. You can discuss any of Bella's actions you personally would do differently.

If I were Bella, there'd be no books. It'd be Jacob all the way.

But, assuming I started off the same as her... I'd kiss Jacob. I was rooting for it to happen, but then Alice had to be there. Hmph.

When Edward left, I would've been sad for a while, but would have recovered more quickly.

No way would I have jumped off the cliff. As soon as I started hearing "Edward" I would have seen a psychiatrist. Or at least not aggravated it. Anyway, I'm terrified of heights. Jumping off a cliff wouldn't even cross my mind beyond seeing the pack doing it.


As for other things I'd do:

- I'd treat Angela better
-I'd tell Lauren exactly what I think of her and it wouldn't be pretty
- I wouldn't even bother with Jessica
-I'd treat Mike better
-I'd call Charlie "dad." He's a good dad; it's not his fault Renee moved so far away.
- I'd spend a lot of time in La Push
- I'd live realistically ever after with Jacob
- I'd go to college

[edwardlover1235]

i wouldnt have kissed jacob hes really nice and sweet but edward deserves better

[Raphael1989]

Would you have done anything differently than Bella? Would you have kissed Jacob? What would you have done when Edward left? Would you have jumped off the cliff?

This is the place to explain what you would have done differently than Bella and how it may have affected the events afterwards. You do not need to stick only to the questions I posed above. You can discuss any of Bella's actions you personally would do differently.

If I were Bella, there'd be no books. It'd be Jacob all the way.

But, assuming I started off the same as her... I'd kiss Jacob. I was rooting for it to happen, but then Alice had to be there. Hmph.

When Edward left, I would've been sad for a while, but would have recovered more quickly.

No way would I have jumped off the cliff. As soon as I started hearing "Edward" I would have seen a psychiatrist. Or at least not aggravated it. Anyway, I'm terrified of heights. Jumping off a cliff wouldn't even cross my mind beyond seeing the pack doing it.


As for other things I'd do:

- I'd treat Angela better
-I'd tell Lauren exactly what I think of her and it wouldn't be pretty
- I wouldn't even bother with Jessica
-I'd treat Mike better
-I'd call Charlie "dad." He's a good dad; it's not his fault Renee moved so far away.
- I'd spend a lot of time in La Push
- I'd live realistically ever after with Jacob
- I'd go to college

Right on! Nice list you got there, took the words out of my mouth...

[Leah Woods]

If I were Bella, first I'd get some hobbies besides cooking. Then I'd buy some books that aren't strictly classics and of course act better towards friends and Charlie. Maybe not Lauren.

I'm pretty sure it'd take longer for me to understand what really Cullens are and I'd get mad at Edward for watching me sleep. That's one of most ridiculous things he ever done.

In New Moon, well I think I'd still befriend with Jacob. I'm not sure about saving Edward, because I'd be still pretty mad at him. Well let's say I saved him, I certainly would've yelled at him on plane and wouldn't accept his proposal.

For Eclipse I'm not sure, because I'm not even sure I'd still be with Edward.