Illegal!?!?

~Vielka~ · Post by **~Vielka~** » Wed Aug 23, 2006 1:18 am

Why are there 3 posts of you talking to yourself?? Are you feeling ok Moonlight??

Anyway...yeah he will eternally be 17, and Bella is now 18...so technically I guess it is illegal...but come on...does it matter?

silverbullet · Post by **silverbullet** » Wed Aug 23, 2006 1:04 pm

I don't really think it matters anymore. I just started this thread to get an idea out. I wanted to see what others thought on the same subject.

Moonlight_Sonata · Post by **Moonlight_Sonata** » Wed Aug 23, 2006 1:25 pm

~Vielka~ wrote:Why are there 3 posts of you talking to yourself?? Are you feeling ok Moonlight??

Anyway...yeah he will eternally be 17, and Bella is now 18...so technically I guess it is illegal...but come on...does it matter?

Hey I wasnt talking to myself! Or was !!!!!!! :twisted:

alifsu17 · Post by **alifsu17** » Wed Aug 23, 2006 4:15 pm

I think that their relationship being illegal is the last thing on their minds...plus, this fact was mentioned earlier, but Edward only looks 17

~Vielka~ · Post by **~Vielka~** » Wed Aug 30, 2006 4:25 am

alifsu17 wrote:I think that their relationship being illegal is the last thing on their minds...plus, this fact was mentioned earlier, but Edward only looks 17

Yeah that and the fact that he can sometimes go for a 25 year old guy. Hopefully thi won't be necessary, but if they were not to turn Bella sometime soon, they still got some time...the cops aren't going to come and arrest her because she is dating someone who doesn't even look illegal.

Granted if she were 60...it would look weird, but I have faith we won't be waiting for long.

Moonlight_Sonata · Post by **Moonlight_Sonata** » Wed Aug 30, 2006 1:42 pm

if bella turns 60, ill jump off a bridge!

Taxi · Post by **Taxi** » Wed Aug 30, 2006 7:28 pm

I think that the law is in place mostly because most people under the age of 18 still, well, act like teenagers, because they are. And obviously, Edward does not act like your typical teenager. I think it's more of a saving-them-from-themselves type of law, ya know? Though, yes, it's still illegal. But since when has the law ever applied to the Cullens?

Lizzie · Post by **Lizzie** » Wed Aug 30, 2006 8:18 pm

Well actually it depends on the state. Some states don't allow the dating to be more than 3 years apart, but in others as long as the teenager is past a ceratin age. Its 17 in some states but 18 on most. Why are we gettin headaches over this? We'll just say he's 18 and no problem. I mean Carlisle does it right? Year after year, they celebrate his "birthday". No one needs to know :wink:

Moonlight_Sonata · Post by **Moonlight_Sonata** » Wed Aug 30, 2006 10:40 pm

what would Charlie say! we are forgeting bella's father is a cop! so if anything, if it were illeagly he would have split them up before new moon! corectamundo?

~Vielka~ · Post by **~Vielka~** » Thu Aug 31, 2006 2:51 pm

Lizzie wrote:Well actually it depends on the state. Some states don't allow the dating to be more than 3 years apart, but in others as long as the teenager is past a ceratin age. Its 17 in some states but 18 on most. Why are we gettin headaches over this? We'll just say he's 18 and no problem. I mean Carlisle does it right? Year after year, they celebrate his "birthday". No one needs to know

We are stuck on the fact that Edward is 17. Yes...this is when his human years came to an end, so he will forever be 17...but this is only known by his family and Bella.

The human population, not just Forks, gets a false Bday somewhere in there. I would assume in Edward's case, he uses his 'human Bday' so that the people at school and town know when this date is, and therefore they assume he ages every year, like normal people.

So, I think Edward started New Moon as an 18 year old, like Bella...if only ine people's eyes. So...no foul play, Charlie doesn't need to freak out...nobody really knows, only Bella.

Again, this age thing...doesn't bother me.

Twilight Lexicon Archive Boards

Illegal!?!?

Who is online