Unused Book Scenes/Details

[Cocoa]

We have a thread to discuss potentially added scenes in the movie (for instance scenes from other character's POV). This is a thread to discuss which scenes and details in the book are not nessasary for the movie plot.

[Spastic Twitch]

It kind of sucks that they won't be able to include everything, and from what I've heard of the movie, they don't really need to include the Port Angeles scene. Which really sucks, because it was one of the best scnes in the book. It might be kind of boring for the movie though... Too much dialogue, i think, which is good for books, but not so much for movies.

[WishIWasBella]

But the Port Angeles scence is where bella confirms that Edward can read minds. Its pivotal to the story. I hope they use it. DO you think that they will include the prom?

[dazzled&breathless]

Yeah, the Port Angeles scene is pivotal. In my mind not for the mind reading thing but because Bella and Edward finally discussing things seriously; like his family and the car crash. Also I think it kind of starts the romance between them as Bella is eating her ravioli and getting a ride home.
I don't think they will include the prom a whole lot because they could easily set up meeting Jacob at her house. Maybe some of the gym scenes will be cut though. They don't exactly move the story line along, they are more of comic relief in a way.

[Kizmet]

It's very hard to be objective about this when you are so obsessed that you are convinced every little last detail is of the utmost importance. I'm trying to think of things they would definitely leave out from a filmmaking standpoint and I can't come up with anything.

[SnowWhite]

It's very hard to be objective about this when you are so obsessed that you are convinced every little last detail is of the utmost importance. I'm trying to think of things they would definitely leave out from a filmmaking standpoint and I can't come up with anything.

I agree i try to come up w/stuff to leave out and i cant. I think if we have to leave out something the gym scenes are not that important but thats about the only thing i can come up with

[sammy101]

I thought I read somewhere that they are doing the prom scene? I think in one of the interviews they mention Bella's prom dress but I can't find it.Not totally sure so don't take my word for it. If they didn't do the prom scene, how would they end the movie? Prom is at the end of the book so it would make sense if they included it. I hope they do the prom scene and the port angeles scene.

[xoxgoodbye]

They have to do the prom scene... I've read that some people's cars are being used for it. They can't leave out Port Angeles scene, where do people here this from? I here people say, "I heard they're not going to put Port Angeles" but they never give out the source. I'm certain there will be a Port Angeles scene... there has to be, I've read it in the....

Okay, I was just skimming through the book and there's a part where Bella goes grocery shopping and then she writes an email to Renee afterwards...

That's the only thing I found that didn't really do any impact in the book, lol, I'm so bad.

[xoxgoodbye]

I thought I read somewhere that they are doing the prom scene? I think in one of the interviews they mention Bella's prom dress but I can't find it.Not totally sure so don't take my word for it. If they didn't do the prom scene, how would they end the movie? Prom is at the end of the book so it would make sense if they included it. I hope they do the prom scene and the port angeles scene.

Sorry for double posting, but the interview is I think the Ashley Green interview.

[Eclipse_Fan_58]

Well i agree with most of you that the port angeles scence isn't sooooo important to be seen. Only i really wanted it to be there cause of well edward really admits that he's a vampire and all the other things about vampires too!